Pan wrote:My wish list for Defrag:
- Standalone version
What is a stand alone version exactly? In terms of IOquake3 it's a VM compiled into the engine binary. I don't see the advantages over VMs.
Pan wrote:- Tutorials you can play with all the gameplay methods and physic tricks
- New guns and items like the portal gun, team arena guns
For tutorials you need official tutorial maps. Since you put so much effor into your mapping tutorials, why don't you give it a go and let people join in?
New items are discussed for a long time now. I see no reason for new items.
Pan wrote:- High resolution contet (there is for textures but not models...) 44 khz stereo sound
- More custom huds
Several thousand man-hours of work are required just to port pak0.pk3. I don't think anyone is willing to do it in his spare time. However, there are high resolution texture packs out there and mappers already use them.
Anyone can make their custom huds. I don't think they every tried to submit them back to cgg. Useless feature, though.
Pan(G) wrote:- Online encyclopedia
- Official Defrag icon and mascot
- Single player campaign or missions
What would the wiki be used for? It'll probably abandoned half finished after a month or so. Nobody uses wikis.
The bunny is fine. Is there a mascot in q3run?
Someone has to write a story for a campain. I can't think of one that would fit. Also this is not Diablo2.
Pan(G) wrote:- An easy way to access or connect a Voice over IP client via or to Defrag
- An extra map folder where you place the pk3 files
- No pk3 or player model limit, no need to repack pk3 files, a game that just loads required pk3 files
- Chat icons like smilies
So this is what the Standalone Version is for. I see.
VoIP is availible in ioquake3 already. They even store it in demos.
Better PK3 parsing and sorting features are a problem limited to defrag. Usually mods don't have to deal with this kind of map output. That's why the ioquake3 dudes don't want to put any effort into solving these issues. Nice to have but not worth the 'stand alone'-effort. Just use ioquake3 or dfengine.